Outsourcing your SOC or hiring: which roles to keep
Managed SOC, in-house SOC or hybrid model: how to choose, which skills to keep in-house and which profiles to hire to stay in control of detection.
Handing monitoring to a managed SOC is often the most sensible decision for an organisation that cannot staff a 24/7 team. But outsourcing monitoring does not remove the need for in-house skills: without someone to manage the provider, alerts keep arriving and nobody really knows what to do with them. This guide helps you choose your model, then identify the profiles to keep or hire in-house.
Three models, three hiring needs
There is no universal right answer. The choice depends on your exposure, the complexity of your information system and your ability to hire and retain analysts.
| Model | What is outsourced | What stays in-house | Typical in-house profiles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fully managed SOC | Collection, detection, first-level triage, 24/7 monitoring | Oversight, decisions, business-side response | A detection lead or experienced analyst reporting to the CISO |
| Hybrid SOC | Out-of-hours monitoring, first-level triage | Advanced triage, business-specific rules, investigation | Tier 2 and tier 3 analysts, detection engineer, SOC manager |
| In-house SOC | Possibly a few pieces (threat intelligence, surge support during a crisis) | Most of the chain | A full rotating team led by a SOC manager |
The hybrid model is common in mid-sized organisations: the provider covers nights and weekends, while the internal team keeps control of anything that requires deep knowledge of the environment.
Good reasons to outsource
Outsourcing monitoring makes sense in several situations:
- You cannot sustain a 24/7 rotation. Continuous monitoring takes several people, on-call duty and an organisation that survives holidays and departures.
- Your environment is fairly standard. Endpoints, email, directory, a few cloud services: an experienced provider knows these well.
- You are starting from scratch. A managed SOC gives you visibility quickly while you build the rest of the team, as described in our article on building a security team.
- Hiring analysts is hard in your area, or your site constraints make rotations unattractive.
Good reasons to keep or build in-house
Conversely, some contexts push towards an internal team, at least in part:
- Your business is specific. In-house applications, industrial environments, financial flows: a generalist provider struggles to detect what it does not understand. Our guide to hiring security talent for industry and OT illustrates this well.
- Your regulatory obligations are heavy. The NIS2 directive (Directive (EU) 2022/2555) requires in-scope entities to send an early warning within 24 hours of becoming aware of a significant incident. Outsourcing detection does not transfer that responsibility: someone in-house must be able to triage and decide quickly.
- You want control over what is detected. Managed SOC rules are often shared across clients. If you want detections tailored to your threats, you need internal skills.
- Knowledge of your environment is an asset. Every investigation run in-house deepens your understanding of your systems. With a provider, part of that knowledge stays with them.
What to keep in-house, whatever the model
Even with a fully managed SOC, some responsibilities cannot be outsourced. They are what define the profiles you need to hire.
- Knowledge of critical assets. Knowing which servers, accounts and applications really matter, and telling the provider when that changes.
- Final triage. The provider flags an unusual login; only someone in-house knows whether it is a planned business trip or a compromise.
- Decisions during an incident. Isolating a production server, revoking access, convening the crisis team: these choices belong to the organisation.
- Contract management. Tracking service levels, reading reports with a critical eye, holding the provider to account when alerts are too many or too thin.
- Continuous improvement. Getting new log sources connected, pointing out blind spots, asking for noisy rules to be reviewed.
- The link with incident response. Knowing who to call, and in what order, when an alert becomes an incident.
One principle guides everything else: never outsource an activity that nobody in-house can understand and challenge.
Which profiles to hire for each model
With a managed SOC: the detection lead
This is the most underestimated profile. It is an experienced analyst, often with a SOC or MSSP background, who becomes the provider's technical counterpart. They read the tickets, re-triage what needs it, know the environment and can argue a case with a supplier.
What to check in this candidate:
- real investigation practice (Windows and Active Directory logs, EDR, SIEM queries);
- the ability to judge the quality of an alert and of a report written by someone else;
- clear written and spoken communication, with the provider as well as with management;
- curiosity about how your business works, not just about the tools.
Our guide to hiring a SOC analyst covers the technical skills to assess. For this role, pay extra attention to oversight and communication.
With a hybrid model: a core of analysts and a detection engineer
The internal core handles advanced triage and investigation. A detection engineer becomes valuable as soon as you want to write your own rules, especially for business applications. Beyond a few analysts, coordinating the internal team and the provider calls for a dedicated lead.
With an in-house SOC: a full team and a manager
An in-house SOC requires several tiers of analysts, sustainable rotations and someone to organise the whole. The key role is the SOC manager, whose profile we describe in our guide to hiring a SOC manager. Plan for the human side from day one: on-call duty, career paths and burnout prevention.
Hiring someone to manage a provider
Managing a managed SOC is a job in its own right, and a standard analyst job description is a poor way to hire for it. A few tips:
- Say it clearly in the job ad. A candidate who expects to investigate all day will be disappointed if they mostly review reports. Conversely, some profiles are looking for exactly this interface role.
- Describe the provider and the contract. Scope monitored, tools, service levels, frequency of review meetings. A good candidate will ask anyway.
- Assess critical judgement. An effective exercise is to hand the candidate a few fictional provider tickets of varying quality and ask which they would accept, which they would send back, and why.
- Check their stance. The role requires being demanding without being confrontational. Ask about a time they had to challenge the work of a supplier or another team.
This kind of exercise reflects how we work: our shortlisted candidates prove their skills on hands-on labs, and we adapt the exercises to the real scope of the role.
Mistakes to avoid
- Outsourcing with no internal counterpart. The provider produces reports nobody reads, and the first real alert gets lost.
- Giving oversight to someone with no technical background. They will not be able to judge alert quality or challenge a hasty conclusion.
- Assuming the contract covers incident response. Check what the provider actually does once an incident is confirmed, and prepare the next step with an incident response lead or a provider identified in advance.
- Bringing everything in-house too soon. Running a 24/7 rotation with two analysts almost always leads to burnout and departures.
- Never revisiting the model. What suited you at the start may no longer fit as your systems or obligations change. A regular review of who does what keeps you from being caught out.
In short
Outsourcing your SOC or building it in-house is not a binary choice. Most organisations combine the two, and the real question is what must stay in your hands: knowledge of your assets, final triage, decisions and oversight of the provider. Those responsibilities define the profiles to hire, starting with a strong detection lead, then a core of analysts and a SOC manager as the in-house share grows.
Need someone to manage your managed SOC or strengthen your detection team? Tell us about your hiring need: a recruiter and a security practitioner scope the role with you, and every shortlisted candidate has proven their skills on a hands-on lab. See how we work.