Skip to content
Cyber Recrut

Counter-offers in cybersecurity hiring: plan ahead

Counter-offers in cybersecurity hiring: spot the risk in the first conversation, build an offer that holds, and stay close to the candidate until day one.

Published on 8 min read

You found the right person, they accepted your offer, and a few days later they tell you they are staying with their current employer. In cybersecurity, where experienced people are rarely actively looking, this is far from unusual. This guide explains why the counter-offer is something you prepare for from the first interview, and how to reduce the risk without pressure or a bidding war.

Why counter-offers are common in cybersecurity

A security professional who leaves takes much more with them than a job title. They know the architecture, the historical exceptions, the detection rules they wrote, the contacts in the business and at suppliers. Their departure also leaves a gap in the on-call rota and, often, a fragile period for the team.

Their employer knows this. Facing a hire it knows will be slow and difficult, it has every reason to try to keep them. The counter-offer then takes several forms:

  • a pay rise, sometimes immediate, sometimes promised for the next review;
  • a new title or a faster promotion;
  • a more interesting project, a team to build, a training budget;
  • better conditions, such as less on-call or more remote work;
  • an appeal to loyalty, from a manager or executive the candidate respects.

None of these responses is illegitimate. Your goal is not to prevent them, but to make sure your candidate makes an informed decision, before signing with you rather than after.

Spotting the risk early

A counter-offer is won or lost long before the offer. It all starts with a simple question, asked early: why is this person thinking of leaving?

Separate deep reasons from surface reasons

Deep reasons are about the work, the team or the setting: a role that no longer grows, an organisation that does not give them the means to act, a heavy on-call load, a worn-out relationship with a manager, the wish to move from compliance to operations or the other way round. A pay rise fixes none of these.

Surface reasons are mostly about pay or title. They are legitimate, but they are exactly what the current employer can fix in a day.

Write down what the candidate tells you, in their own words. You will need it later, when the counter-offer arrives.

Signals worth your attention

SignalWhat it may meanHow to respond
The candidate only talks about salaryTheir motivation may vanish with a raiseExplore what they want from the role beyond pay
They have never raised their concerns internallyTheir employer may discover the problem and offer to fix itAsk what they have already tried to change their situation
They are running several processes at onceThey may first be testing their market valueDiscuss it openly and understand how they will choose
They are very attached to their manager or teamThe emotional side will weigh when they resignIntroduce them early to their future colleagues
They are unsure about when to resignThe decision is not settled yetClear up their doubts before sending the offer

None of these signals rules a candidate out. They simply show you where to focus.

Ask the question openly

The most effective approach is to talk about the counter-offer before it exists. Once the first interviews are done, simply ask: "If your employer asks you to stay, what would tip the balance?"

The answer is telling. A candidate who replies straight away that nothing would keep them, because they want a different job or a different environment, has solid motivation. A candidate who admits a raise would make them think gives you valuable information: your offer will have to win on more than the number.

This is not an interrogation. It shows the candidate you understand their situation, and it helps them put their own decision into words. Candidates who are ready for this step handle it much better, as we explain from their side in our article on resigning and notice periods in cybersecurity.

Build an offer that holds

An offer holds against a counter-offer when it answers the reasons for leaving the candidate gave you, not just their salary expectations.

  1. Tie the offer to their stated motivations. If they wanted more autonomy, describe exactly what they will decide. If they wanted less on-call, write down the real rota.
  2. Be fair on pay from the start. A low offer in the hope of negotiating later leaves a gap the current employer can easily close. Agree the salary range before the first interview.
  3. Put what matters in writing. Remote work, on-call, training budget, bonus: anything unwritten will be compared with a verbal promise on the other side.
  4. Show what comes next. Career prospects, the projects of the next twelve months, the role's place in the team: this is what a counter-offer struggles to match.
  5. Move fast. Every day between your decision and the offer is a day the candidate may mention leaving and receive a proposal.

Speed matters most. We break down where time is lost in our analysis of time to hire in cybersecurity. Preparing the offer before the final interview is one of the simplest levers.

What not to do

Some understandable reflexes have the opposite effect:

  • Criticising the current employer. The candidate has colleagues and memories there. You push them to defend it.
  • Applying pressure with an artificial deadline. An offer "valid for 48 hours" suggests you fear the comparison.
  • Outbidding without thinking. If the candidate comes back with a counter-offer, raising yours to beat it builds a relationship based only on money, and can create a gap with the rest of the team.
  • Overstating the risk of staying. Claiming that someone kept by a counter-offer always leaves anyway is not an established fact. It sounds hollow.
  • Going quiet after signature. The notice period is exactly when the counter-offer arrives.

Stay close during the notice period

In France, a manager-level employee often has a notice period of several months, depending on the collective agreement. During that time the candidate still works for their employer, who has plenty of time to come back to them. Silence on your side leaves the field open.

Simple steps are enough:

  • a call from the future manager in the week after signature;
  • an invitation to meet the team, over lunch or an informal catch-up;
  • useful material to prepare their arrival: tools, first topics, public documentation;
  • a regular, low-key check-in to make sure everything is fine;
  • an onboarding plan shared before day one, as for onboarding a SOC analyst.

The aim is not to watch the candidate, but to make their future role concrete. The more they can picture it, the less a last-minute proposal will sway them.

If the counter-offer comes anyway

It can happen even when everything was done right. The candidate calls, a little embarrassed, to say they have been asked to stay.

Start by listening. Ask what they were offered and, above all, whether it solves the reasons for leaving they gave you at the start. This is where your notes help: you can remind them, without contradicting them, of what they told you about their current role.

Then there are two cases:

  • The offer genuinely solves their reasons for leaving. Respect their decision. A candidate who joins you reluctantly will not stay long, and a preserved relationship can turn into a hire later, or a referral.
  • The offer only solves part of the problem. Help them compare the two situations as a whole. If an adjustment to your offer is justified by the market and consistent with your pay structure, it can be discussed. Otherwise, it is better not to match.

Either way, stay courteous. The security world is small, and how you handle this moment will be talked about. It is part of your employer brand.

In short

Anticipating a counter-offer takes no special technique, just attention at every stage:

  • understand from the first conversation why the candidate wants to leave;
  • raise the counter-offer question before sending the offer;
  • build a fair, written proposal tied to their motivations;
  • move fast between decision and offer;
  • stay in touch throughout the notice period.

It is the same work that helps you approach senior cyber profiles who were not looking: listen first, convince second.

Hiring a cybersecurity profile and want to secure the offer stage? Tell us about your need. Our recruiters follow every candidate until their first day, notice period included, and our shortlisted candidates prove their skills on hands-on labs before you meet them. See how we work.

Related articles